Connect with us


Special Report: Understanding Phuket corruption

Legacy Phuket Gazette



Special Report: Understanding Phuket corruption | The Thaiger

PHUKET: Though the recently deceased Phuket Provincial Administration Organization (PPAO) President Paiboon Upatising will no longer be called to task for alleged corruption in the development of the PPAO Hospital, the case will continue, confirms Preechanun Pumlek, Chief of the Phuket office of the National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC).

To see the much respected and loved elected official removed from office through Article 44 might have come as a surprise to those new to the island. However, seasoned expats, frequent visitors and local Thais know the island is rife with corruption at all levels. Nonetheless, prior to his death from colon cancer, Mr Paiboon was sure that the charges levied against him by the Auditor General Office (OAG) would be swept away.

Corruption is not unique to Phuket, or even Thailand, which was recently ranked 85 out of 175 countries by global corruption watchdog Transparency International (TI). However, rampant graft in Phuket is driven by several unique qualities of the province that are not seen to such a degree elsewhere in Thailand, explains Surin Bamrungphol, founder and president of the Phuket Anti-Corruption Network.

“Three major factors continue to contribute to corruption on the island: the tradition of illegally fast-tracking projects, which has been around since the tin mining era; the vast amount of money flowing into the island via the tourism industry; and the nationwide standardization of government employee salaries regardless of the cost of living,” said Mr Surin.

“Perhaps the largest issue of the three comes down to income. Officers do not make enough money to live in Phuket, as it is significantly more expensive to live here than any other province. Additionally, Phuket often attracts high-ranking officers from outside the province, who the local officers have to host and support with money from their own pockets.”

From 2007 to 2012, overall inflation in Thailand was measured at about 16 per cent, but Phuket saw a 5-year inflation rate of 26 per cent. In other words, during that period, the cost of living in Phuket rose at a rate about 60 per cent higher than that for Thailand as a whole. Nonetheless, government officers are paid based on their rank and position, with no adjustments made for location.

To better understand corruption on the island and to highlight which offices are the ‘most corrupt’, Dr Surin began a three-part, Thai-language corruption survey in 2013. Dr Surin is not yet ready to release the results for 2015, which explore solutions for corruption on the island. However, he did go into details about last year’s results.

From May 2013 into 2014, 1,200 surveys were handed out to students, government employees, local business owners and residents of all ages. The team received 611 responses.

“The questionnaires asked participants to rank the top ten most corrupt offices in Phuket. Additionally, it sought information about the type of corruption perceived or witnessed,” Dr Surin said. “We asked questions such as, ‘When you did official business with this department, did you have to pay money under the table?'”

A number of studies have called into question the validity of survey-based data collection methods. Probably the most widely debated issue, with regard to corruption surveys, is the relative value or reliability of perception-based versus experience-based data, reports Transparency International (TI) in its publication ‘Gateway Corruption Assessment Toolbox’.

“While there is far from a consensus on the issue, experience surveys are usually considered more reliable to measure petty corruption, while perception surveys are deemed more appropriate for shedding light on the prevalence of grand corruption (policy capture, nepotism and so on). Furthermore, while there is some good evidence of a strong correlation between corruption experience and perception, this trend is uneven across countries,” the publication states.

“There may, in some cases, be increased levels of tolerance toward (and hence more favorable perceptions of) corruption in areas where corruption experience is high, or conversely, heightened awareness of (and hence less favorable perceptions of) corruption in areas where there is a greater focus on tackling corruption by authorities.

“Other factors which may affect the perception of the level of corruption in a country, regardless of actual experience, include economic development, trust in government institutions, press freedom, population size, education, age, employment status, or the business environment.”

The business environment in Phuket is exceptionally fertile for corruption, says Dr Surin.

“The island is developing rapidly, with new businesses opening all the time, bringing in fresh money,” he says. “Additionally, more and more people are moving to Phuket to take advantage of the economic growth, despite the increased cost of living. These factors make it a prime location for the continued growth of corrupt practices.”

The top ten ‘most corrupt’ offices out of the 25 options presented in the survey in 2014 were the local police; the Land Department in Phuket Town and Thalang; local government bodies, including the Phuket Provincial Organization (PPAO), local administration organizations (OrBorTor) and tessabaans; Thalang District Office; Muang District Office; Kathu District Office; Phuket Immigration Police; Natural Resources and Environment Phuket Office; the Phuket Tourist Police; and Satree Phuket School.

As the survey was in Thai-language only, it was not sent to international tourists or members of the expat community, notes Dr Surin. Nonetheless, Phuket Immigration Police and the Phuket Tourist Police made the top ten list.

A number of corrupt activities were flagged in the survey as regularly occurring in Phuket. They ranged from getting students into well-established schools, to officers making payments to higher-ranking officials in order to secure better positions.

“The list of forms of corruption is extensive. However, expediting services is a commonly cited form of it, as is paying bribes to gain special permission for services, registrations or verifications. There were also allegations of medical equipment purchases being centered around the medical company providing free overseas trips to doctors,” said Dr Surin. “However, corruption in the police forces, which made up three of the top ten government bodies in 2014, is by far the worse problem.”

In general, commanders are effectively in charge of controlling their officers, explains Dr Surin.

“And ultimately, money buys loyalty,” he adds.

Phuket Provincial Police Deputy Commander Peerayuth Karajedee was not surprised when confronted with the results from last year’s survey.

“I cannot deny that there is a problem with police corruption throughout Thailand, including Phuket,” Col Peerayuth said. “The Royal Thai Police is a big organization and every organization has good and bad people working for it.”

However, the results ultimately are not helpful for police attempting to rein in corruption, said Col Peerayuth.

“The results show overall perceptions, but fail to provide the leads necessary for us to take action,” Col Peerayuth said. “We need everyone out there to help us ensure government officers are dutifully fulfilling their responsibilities. The police force in Phuket is simply too small given the number of people on the island.”

Dr Surin hopes that his anti-corruption network will continue to strengthen, in order to take more direct action and support police officers attempting to curb corruption.

“At a national level, we already have organizations that do this. However, having our own anti-corruption network on Phuket is more effective,” he said. “This is the power and responsibility of a civil society. We utilize numerous aspects of Phuket for our own benefit and should not ignore illegal activities here.”

Dr Surin says that one of the largest battles in the war on corruption is the battle against apathy.

“Some people think corruption has nothing to do with them because they do not see how they are directly affected,” Dr Surin notes. “However, we are all affected by corruption. We pay taxes and our taxes must be spent for the benefit of our society as a whole, not just to be put into the pockets of some individuals.”

The alleged misappropriation of government funds is exactly what led to the suspension of Mr Paiboon by the OAG, which recently launched a public campaign about its fight against corruption.

“I would urge everyone to keep an eye on government projects,” said OAG Auditor-General Pisit Leelavachiropas. “If you see anything suspicious about the way state money is spent, please inform us through our anonymous hotline.”

The OAG can be contacted at 02 271-8000 at all time.

— Chutharat Plerin

Keep in contact with The Thaiger by following our Facebook page.

Read more headlines, reports & breaking news in Phuket. Or catch up on your Thailand news.

Archiving articles from the Phuket Gazette circa 1998 - 2017. View the Phuket Gazette online archive and Digital Gazette PDF Prints.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Now you see him, now you don’t… Patong Police hunt foreigner over $30k theft

Greeley Pulitzer



Now you see him, now you don’t… Patong Police hunt foreigner over $30k theft | The Thaiger

PHOTO: Patong Police

Patong Police have yet to develop any tangible leads tracking down a foreigner who made off with US$30,000 in cash from a currency exchange booth in Kalim, north of Patong in Phuket, last Tuesday.

The man is about 168 centimetres tall with grey hair and around 60 years old, Patong police told The Phuket News.

“We have no clue what nationality he is.”

He was last seen at the currency exchange booth wearing a purple polo shirt, blue jeans and black cap. Police have checked hotels in the area, police stations across the island and Phuket Immigration, but have yet to join the dots and come up with firm leads.

“Investigators have checked CCTV in the area and collected what evidence we have but we still do not know the man’s name or where he was staying.”

The man had visited the booth several times before Tuesday, when he disappeared with the $30,000 in US banknotes, according to police.

“It was always small amounts”, he added, noting that the amounts didn’t warrant staff at the exchange booth to check the man’s passport before making the exchange.

The man arrived at the booth again at about 1pm on Tuesday, saying that he had 900,000 baht cash to exchange.

SOURCE: The Phuket News

Keep in contact with The Thaiger by following our Facebook page.
Continue Reading


Mystery surrounds security guard found dead in his Phuket room

The Thaiger



Mystery surrounds security guard found dead in his Phuket room | The Thaiger

PHOTOS: Phuket Hot News

The security guard of a hotel in Nai Yang, northern Phuket, 52 year old Yingyot Butsabong, from Maha Sarakham province, was found dead yesterday (October 16) in his room. Police remain mystified how the man came to grief.

A woman named Supattra received a call from the hotel he worked at and was informed that he didn’t show up at work yesterday, so she went to his apartment to check on him.

She saw that his room was locked from the inside, so used the key she had in her possession to open the room and found Yingyot laying on the floor, face down. She thought he was just sleeping so she tried to wake him up but once she flipped him, she found that he already passed away.

She immediately called Saku police, and once on the scene, police found that there was some blood on the floor. The man had a 2 centimetre wound on his left eyebrow which was deep into his skull. There was also a wound on his chin about 1 centimetre long and about a centimetre deep. His left eye had a bruise which looked like he was attacked by a hard object.

Police report that he had been dead for around four hours in the room.

The room was not ransacked and there was no sign of fighting or theft. His body has been sent to Thalang Hospital for a detailed autopsy and to look into the cause of death.

SOURCE: Phuket Hot News

Keep in contact with The Thaiger by following our Facebook page.
Continue Reading


‘Always Smile Journey’ raises fund to provide free English classes for underprivileged people

Nattha Thepbamrung



‘Always Smile Journey’ raises fund to provide free English classes for underprivileged people | The Thaiger

On October 18, the ‘Always Smile Journey’ group and its partners will host an exhibition with plenty of fun activities at the Yak Yai Market, near Chalong Circle, in Phuket. This event was designed to raise funds to provide free English classes for underprivileged people on the island of Phuket on Saturdays and Sundays. The group does not accept donations but aims to raise money through the sales of the products available at the event.

‘Always Smile Journey’ raises fund to provide free English classes for underprivileged people | News by The Thaiger

From 2 pm to 8 pm, there will be a number of artists, musicians and performers who will keep the attendees entertained along the way. There will be a short film about His Majesty King Rama 9 as well as fun activities and games for kids and families, which are all free of charge.

The big bike crew is also a part of this event. They will ride a parade from Rawai Beach heading to the market and showcase their gorgeous two-wheel buddies.

One of the highlights of the Always Smile Journey exhibition is the ‘Happening’ artists group, who will draw and paint a picture of the His Majesty King Rama 9 under the name ‘Street Art King Bhumibol’ on a 4×10 meter sign live at the event so the guests will experience this large-scale art in action. The Happening will also offer portrait sketching for the participants.

‘Always Smile Journey’ raises fund to provide free English classes for underprivileged people | News by The Thaiger

One of the works created by the Happening team; a painting of HM the King Rama 9 on a huge wall (Photo credit: Chawat Chumpasan)

There will also be some western menus available at the event which will be donated to underprivileged children.

This free English class project has over seven years of experience through its cooperation working with individuals and other charity organizations. Throughout the years, the group visited several areas such as Ban Laem Hoy School, Ban Bopud School and Ban Angthong School in Samui, Surat Thani province, Ban Bueng Ao Oun School and Ban Kakoh Rayong, in Surin province, Jalae Village of Lahu (Muser) in Chiang Rai province, as well as community education centers in Siem Reap, Cambodia and in Luang Prabang, in Laos.

This event is a cooperation between several groups, including Happening, Yak Yai Market and Arrow Media, Tattoo artist group, Thonburi Art School Alumni, International School of Tourism, Suratthani Rajabhat University, big bike group from Phuket, artists/performers/musicians from many provinces as well as several businesses across Phuket.

Keep in contact with The Thaiger by following our Facebook page.
Continue Reading

The Thaiger Newsletter

Keep up with all the day’s news. Subscribe here.

The latest news and information from Thailand.

* indicates required

ชมวาทะเด็ดธนาธร ให้การศาลรัฐธรรมนูญ คดีวีลัค ทำงานการเมืองเพราะอยากเปลี่ยนแปลงสังคม | The Thaiger
ข่าวการเมือง10 hours ago

ชมวาทะเด็ดธนาธร ให้การศาลรัฐธรรมนูญ คดีวีลัค ทำงานการเมืองเพราะอยากเปลี่ยนแปลงสังคม

ตรวจหวย 16/10/62 รางวัลที่ 1 เลขท้าย 2 ตัว 3 ตัว เลขหน้า 3 ตัว และรางวัลอื่น ๆ | The Thaiger
ตรวจหวย2 days ago

ตรวจหวย 16/10/62 รางวัลที่ 1 เลขท้าย 2 ตัว 3 ตัว เลขหน้า 3 ตัว และรางวัลอื่น ๆ

ตรวจหวย 16 ตุลาคม 2562 ผลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล 16/10/62 | The Thaiger
ตรวจหวย2 days ago

ตรวจหวย 16 ตุลาคม 2562 ผลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล 16/10/62

ถ่ายทอดสด “สลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล” 16 ตุลาคม 2562 ลุ้นรางวัลที่ 1 สด ๆ | The Thaiger
ตรวจหวย2 days ago

ถ่ายทอดสด “สลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล” 16 ตุลาคม 2562 ลุ้นรางวัลที่ 1 สด ๆ

หนุ่มแท็กซี่ฉาว ท้าต่อยเจ้าของธุรกิจเต๊นท์ กลางงานสนามหลวง | The Thaiger
ข่าว3 days ago

หนุ่มแท็กซี่ฉาว ท้าต่อยเจ้าของธุรกิจเต๊นท์ กลางงานสนามหลวง

ไทยแชมป์วอลเลย์บอลอาเซียนกรังด์ปรีซ์สนาม 2 รางวัลรายบุคคล | The Thaiger
วอลเลย์บอล2 weeks ago

ไทยแชมป์วอลเลย์บอลอาเซียนกรังด์ปรีซ์สนาม 2 รางวัลรายบุคคล

ตรวจหวย1ตุลาคม2562 ผลรางวัลที่ 1 เลขท้าย 2 ตัว 3 ตัว เลขหน้า 3 ตัว และรางวัลอื่น ๆ | The Thaiger
ตรวจหวย2 weeks ago

ตรวจหวย1ตุลาคม2562 ผลรางวัลที่ 1 เลขท้าย 2 ตัว 3 ตัว เลขหน้า 3 ตัว และรางวัลอื่น ๆ

ถ่ายทอดสดหวย 1 ตุลาคม 2562 ลุ้นรางวัลที่ 1 สลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล | The Thaiger
ตรวจหวย2 weeks ago

ถ่ายทอดสดหวย 1 ตุลาคม 2562 ลุ้นรางวัลที่ 1 สลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล

สีจิ้นผิงกล่าวสุนทรพจน์ ครบรอบ 70 ปีก่อตั้งสาธารณรัฐประชาชนจีน -ลิงก์ถ่ายทอดสด | The Thaiger
ต่างประเทศ3 weeks ago

สีจิ้นผิงกล่าวสุนทรพจน์ ครบรอบ 70 ปีก่อตั้งสาธารณรัฐประชาชนจีน -ลิงก์ถ่ายทอดสด

คลิปไฮไลท์วอลเลย์บอลเวิลด์คัพ 2019 นัดที่ 5 | The Thaiger
วอลเลย์บอล4 weeks ago

คลิปไฮไลท์วอลเลย์บอลเวิลด์คัพ 2019 นัดที่ 5

คลิปไฮไลท์ วอลเลย์บอลเวิลด์คัพ 2019 นัดที่ 1 | The Thaiger
วอลเลย์บอล1 month ago

คลิปไฮไลท์ วอลเลย์บอลเวิลด์คัพ 2019 นัดที่ 1

Paramount เตรียมรีเมค FACE/OFF หนังบู๊ระดับตำนาน | The Thaiger
หนัง1 month ago

Paramount เตรียมรีเมค FACE/OFF หนังบู๊ระดับตำนาน

ประยุทธ์ โต้ รัฐบาลไหนก็มีตำหนิทั้งนั้น “ถึงเวลาก็อ้างอย่างที่ผมอ้าง” | The Thaiger
ข่าวการเมือง1 month ago

ประยุทธ์ โต้ รัฐบาลไหนก็มีตำหนิทั้งนั้น “ถึงเวลาก็อ้างอย่างที่ผมอ้าง”

อารัมภบท รักฉุดใจนายฉุกเฉิน My ambulance ตอนแรก 6 กันยานี้ | The Thaiger
บันเทิง1 month ago

อารัมภบท รักฉุดใจนายฉุกเฉิน My ambulance ตอนแรก 6 กันยานี้

วอลเลย์บอลหญิงชิงแชมป์ยุโรป 2019 โฉมหน้า 4 ทีมตัดเชือกรอบรอง | The Thaiger
วอลเลย์บอล1 month ago

วอลเลย์บอลหญิงชิงแชมป์ยุโรป 2019 โฉมหน้า 4 ทีมตัดเชือกรอบรอง