Prosthetic police probe: Thai man accuses hopalong cop of wife’s murder confession coercion
A Thai man accused a hopalong cop with a prosthetic leg at Aranyaprathet Police Station in the Isaan province of Sa Kaeo of torture and forcing him into confessing to the murder of his wife.
Buaphan Tansu was brutally assaulted and murdered by a group of five teenagers, who are now in police custody. Initially, the police wrongly arrested 54 year old Panya Kongsaenkham, as the main suspect. He was later released when the real perpetrators were identified.
However, suspicions arose about why Panya confessed to a crime he did not commit.
A voice recording of a police officer from Aranyaprathet Police Station and information from Panya’s relatives were released, strengthening the suspicion. The Deputy Commissioner of the Royal Thai Police (RTP), Surachate “Big Joke” Hakparn, intervened in the case to seek justice for Panya and his wife.
Big Joke reported yesterday, January 18, that the deputy superintendent of the Aranyaprathet Police Station was the voice in the recording, and he confirmed Panya had been tortured.
Big Joke told Amarin TV that his team showed pictures of every officer at Aranyaprathet Police Station to Panya and he pointed to only one officer who tortured him on the day.
Hopalong cop
Panya insisted that only one officer tortured him on the day. He remembered that the officer had a prosthetic leg. He covered Panya’s head with a black plastic bag, ordered Panya to take off his shirt, and lowered the air conditioning temperature. The torture and threats went on for over nine hours, and Panya confessed to the murder because he was exhausted and suffering.
The police officer was allegedly later identified as Police Senior Sergeant Major Phisake Puangmalee. Phisake and other relevant police officers were questioned about the incident yesterday. Phisake refused to give an interview with the media.
The investigation into police abuse is ongoing, with ongoing questioning of the five teenagers involved in the murder and their parents. ThaiRath reported that four additional victims have lodged complaints against the teenage group for their previous violent acts.
Panya has been relocated to the Centre for Homeless Protection in the central province of Pathum Thani to address his issues with alcoholism. Reports indicate that Panya appears more at ease after the latest round of questioning.
In an interview with PPTV HD, Big Joke expressed his belief that the accused police officer coerced Panya into confessing to the murder in a bid to swiftly close the case and garner praise for his supposed exemplary work. He was fairly certain that the officer had no intention of aiding the five teenage murderers in evading charges.
UPDATE 2: Sa Kaeo police allegedly threaten Thai man to confess to his wife’s murder
The Deputy Commissioner of the Royal Thai Police (RTP), Surachate “Big Joke” Hakparn, stepped in to oversee the inquiry into the murder of a Thai woman, Buaphan Thansu. This intervention followed accusations against officers from Aranyaprathet Police Station in the Isaan province of Sa Kaeo that they were alleged to have coerced the woman’s husband into confessing to the crime.
Buaphan’s, 54 year old husband, Panya Kongsaenkham, confessed to murdering his wife Buaphan by beating her with a chair and dumping her body in a pond near the abandoned petrol station in Sakaeo. However, CCTV footage showed the real killers were five Thai teenagers aged between 13 and 16. As a result, Panya was released from prison.
The public and media were intrigued as to why Panya initially confessed to the murder. It is suspected that Panya confessed due to police threats, with some speculating that a police officer— who happens to be the father of one of the suspects— played a role in coercing Panya’s confession.
Several news agencies tried to contact Panya but he disappeared and blocked all media contacts after his release. After the suspension went viral on social media, Panya was summoned by the police for further questioning and investigation yesterday, January 17.
Non-profit organisation Win Win Foundation Vice President Donchanok Boonyotayarn reported to Channel 3 that his team talked with Panya’s relatives. The relatives told the foundation that Panya had been tortured and threatened into confessing to the murder.
According to the foundation, a group of Thai men, believed to be police officers, covered Panya’s head with a black plastic bag, chained him, and threatened him to confess to the murder.
Superintendent’s alleged confession
The foundation told the Daily News that they contacted the superintendent of the Aranyaprathet Police Station about the act, and the superintendent admitted that his superiors had done it. The voice recording of the phone call was released by PPTV HD today, January 18.
In one part of the call, the superintendent said…
“I asked them why they did it and they told me they just did it for fun. They were just playing a prank on Panya. They confessed it and said they did not do it seriously.”
PPTV HD did not confirm whether the statement in the phone call came from the superintendent.
The Deputy Commissioner Big Joke later joined the investigation. Big Joke reported that the information from Panya’s relatives and the voice recording was the new evidence in the case. He had not verified the evidence but assured the public that any police officers involved in the act would be transferred from their posts during the investigation.
Big Joke stated that he reviewed the investigation processes of the Aranyaprathet Police Station from the security camera footage and found that it took officers more than two hours to escort Panya from where he was arrested to the police station.
Big Joke said the distance between the two places was not far and two hours was considered too long. The 53 year old deputy police chief revealed he plans further questioning with Panya and the police officers about what happened during those two hours.
UPDATE 1: Sa Kaeo murder sparks debate over police transparency and leniency on teenage murderers
The murder of a Thai woman in the Isaan province of Sa Kaeo sparked a debate about the lenient punishment handed out to teenage murderers and raised concerns about the transparency of the Thai police.
The dead body of a 47 year old Thai woman named Buaphan Thansu was found in a pond near an abandoned petrol station in the Aranyaprathet district of Sa Kaeo on January 12. Her husband, 54 year old Panya Kongsaenkham, was arrested as the main suspect after he confessed to the murder.
While Panya was in police custody awaiting further legal proceedings, a reporter from Channel 8, Natdanai Narath, released CCTV footage of the murder to the public. The footage absolved Panya of the murder and implicated five teenagers aged between 13 and 16, who physically assaulted Buaphan until she died.
The five teenagers were arrested and admitted to the murder. One of the youths is the son of a deputy inspector general at Aranyaprathet Police Station, the police station handling Buaphan’s case. Another is the son of an officer at the Sa Kaeo Provincial Immigration Office.
Panya was later released. He told the media that he confessed to the murder under pressure from locals in the area. He insisted that no one forced or threatened him to confess to the murder.
After reporters asked why Panya could re-enact the murder if he did not commit it, he laughed before leaving the press conference in a pickup. Police reported that they sent Panya to his relatives in Surin province. Police added that Panya has disappeared since his release. No one has been able to contact him since then.
Teenage killers
Buaphan’s case sparked a debate on whether young offenders should receive the same punishment as adults because the details of how the teenagers killed Buaphan were very disturbing.
A leaked voice recording of the teenage killers talking to other friends was shared on social media. In the voice recording, the teenage killer, believed to be the police officer’s son, pushed Buaphan into the water until she drowned before dumping her body in the pond.
Locals also recounted several abusive behaviours of the teenagers, saying they disturbed people in the community when they gathered to drink alcohol and take kratom. They reportedly committed thefts and raped a 19 year old girl and their names were allegedly cleared by the police father.
The case extended beyond the juvenile offenders’ punishment, raising concerns about police procedures and investigation transparency. Many are inquisitive about what might have transpired with Panya if Channel 8 reporter Natdanai had not released the CCTV footage of kicking the woman to death.
Somprasong Yentuam, the Commander of the Provincial Police Region 2, insisted that the police remained unconvinced by Panya’s confession and had acquired the CCTV footage before the Channel 8 reporter. He maintained that the reporter could not access the footage without police permission.
Somprasong contended that even in the absence of CCTV footage, Panya would still have been released because the court would dismiss charges due to insufficient evidence supporting Panya’s statements. He emphasised that the officers investigated the case diligently and did not provide assistance to the teenage killers, despite their parents being officers.
Both police officers from the Immigration Bureau and Aranyaprathet Police Station were reassigned during the investigation. Somprasong stated that legal action would be taken if the investigation revealed any misuse of power on their part.
ORIGINAL STORY: Thai man wrongly arrested for wife’s death, CCTV exposes 5 teenage murderers (video)
Police arrested a Thai man who confessed to murdering his wife, only to later discover his innocence and identify five teenagers as the guilty perpetrators of the crime in the Isaan province of Sa Kaeo. Police discovered their error upon reviewing CCTV footage.
Aranyaprathet Police Station officers in Sa Kaeo were alerted to the discovery of a dead body in a pond near Sriaranyithai School and an abandoned petrol station in the Aranyaprathet district at midnight on January 12.
The lifeless body of Buaphan Thansu, a 47 year old woman, was discovered submerged in a pond, lying face down. She was dressed in a sleeveless shirt and long black trousers, showing injuries to her head and face. Residents revealed Buaphan was battling with mental health issues and often roamed the area.
An initial autopsy revealed that Buaphan was murdered and died at least one day before her discovery. Her husband, 54 year old Panya Kongsaenkham, was arrested as the main suspect.
Panya confessed to officers that he and his wife were drunk and argued. Panya added that he hit his wife on the head with a chair until she died. Officers then took Panya to court for temporary detention before transferring him to the Sa Kaeo Provincial Prison.
Police later discovered that Panya was also mentally ill and provided a false confession statement to officers. He was not the murderer and was not involved in the death of his wife as he confessed. Officers then checked CCTV cameras near the crime scene and discovered that five teenagers were the murderers.
Officers witnessed footage of five teenagers physically assaulting Buaphan at around 10pm on January 10 until she lost consciousness. The teenagers were seen carrying Buaphan into their pickup truck and driving to Sriaranyithai School. They continued to assault the married woman at the school until she died and discarded her body in the pond.
The five suspects, aged between 13 to 16, were summoned for questioning and admitted to the murder. They claimed that Buaphan threw a bottle at them making them angry so they attacked her.
According to the police, the murderers were juveniles, so more detailed questioning would take place later with child specialists and child psychologists. Officers would question Panya again about why he confessed to the crime even though he was not involved.
One of the teenage suspects is reported to be the son of a police officer in the area, raising concerns about whether or not the police officer was involved in Panya’s confession.
